Slip Dog Training Choke Collar review

Have you been looking for a simple, effective training collar that helps control leash-pulling without being heavy or complicated?

Product overview: Slip Dog Training Choke Collar – Round Nylon Rope No Pull P-Collar for Small Medium Large Dogs (Black S)

I tested the Slip Dog Training Choke Collar – Round Nylon Rope No Pull P-Collar for Small Medium Large Dogs (Black S) over several weeks to see how it performs in everyday walking and training situations. This is a lightweight P-style slip collar made from round nylon rope with a leather-tailored connection point, intended for dogs that pull on the leash and for general training cues.

What’s included and what I received

I got the collar itself and nothing else in the package—no leash, no instructions beyond a small tag. The collar comes ready to use, and I appreciated that it requires minimal setup. I like that it’s clean and straightforward; you can put it on, adjust, and go.

Key specifications

I always want the facts at a glance, so I created a table to make size and fit easy to compare. This helped me decide whether the S size was appropriate for my smaller dogs and whether other sizes would suit my larger friends.

Feature	S (Black S)	M
Rope diameter	0.8 cm / 0.31 in	1.0 cm / 0.4 in
Total length	40 cm / 15.7 in	50 cm / 19.7 in
Recommended weight range	2–15 kg	10–30 kg
Collar design	P-collar / slip choke	P-collar / slip choke
Material	Round nylon rope + leather tailor connection	Round nylon rope + leather tailor connection
Washable	Yes	Yes
Intended use	Training, no-pull control	Training, no-pull control
Best for	Small breeds, puppies	Medium to larger small breeds

Design and materials

I pay close attention to materials because durability and comfort are tied to what the collar is made of. The Slip Dog Training Choke Collar used a straightforward combination of nylon rope and a leather-tailored connector, which gave a familiar and functional look.

Rope and nylon quality

The round nylon rope feels smooth and slightly glossy. It has enough stiffness so that it forms a proper loop but remains flexible. I noticed the S size rope is thinner (0.8 cm), which I liked for smaller muzzle and neck sizes. The nylon tolerates the weather reasonably well and is less likely to fray quickly compared with cheap ropes I’ve seen.

Leather tailor connection

The collar’s leather tailor connection is a small but important detail. It’s stitched to hold the ends and acts as the anchor for the slider and when the collar tightens. The leather section felt sturdy upon first inspection, and the stitching looked clean and secure. I appreciate this because a weak connection point can be the first failure point in slip collars.

Washability and durability

The collar is washable, which I tested by hand-washing after muddy walks. Nylon rinses easily and dried quickly. The leather piece handled the cleaning without obvious damage, though I avoided soaking it for too long. Over weeks of regular use the nylon maintained its shape, and there was no noticeable weakening in the stitching or rope.

Sizing and fit

Getting the size right is essential with slip collars. I used the S size for smaller dogs and compared it mentally to M for slightly larger dogs so I could report what I observed across weight ranges.

Choosing the right size

The manufacturer recommends S for dogs 2–15 kg and M for 10–30 kg. I trust those ranges for a safe starting point, but I always advise measuring your dog’s neck and then considering the collar’s total length and diameter. For a small dog with a 22–30 cm neck, the S should work. For a dog with a fuller neck or a thicker coat, I’d consider M.

How to measure your dog

I measure gently with a soft tape measure, allowing two fingers between tape and the dog’s neck to avoid a too-tight fit. With a slip collar, it’s important that the collar can sit comfortably over the head and tighten when needed, without being so long that it slips off or too short that it chokes at rest. I tested by putting the collar on in its resting position and trying a few training tugs to ensure it tightened evenly and released smoothly.

Comfort and wearability

Comfort matters to me because a training tool that causes pain or irritation will damage the trust I’m building with a dog. I watched how my dogs reacted to wearing this collar for walks and training sessions.

Weight and feel on different breeds

The collar is very light—one of its strengths. On smaller dogs, the S felt minimal and didn’t pull the head down or slide excessively. On lean medium dogs, the M felt proportional. The lightweight design means the dog mostly accepts it as a normal collar rather than an intrusive device, which helps me get consistent behavior during training.

Skin and coat considerations

Because it’s a nylon rope, it can rub if left on too tightly or if the dog is very active. I made sure the collar wasn’t left snugly tightened when the dog wasn’t on a leash. For dogs with very short hair, I observed slight red marks after extreme pulling sessions, which resolved quickly. For dogs with longer coats the rope moved over the fur with less friction but required occasional adjustment to avoid tangling in particularly long hair.

Training performance

The whole point of a P-collar is to give a quick, controlled correction that redirects behavior without heavy force. I used the collar for basic walk training, recall reinforcement, and short correction cues.

How the P-collar design works

The P-collar (also called a slip or choke collar) tightens when pressure is applied to the leash and releases when pressure is removed. The round rope profile and the sliding loop in this design create a clean, immediate cue. I appreciate how intuitive the mechanism is; when my dog lunged or pulled, the collar tightened just enough to remind them to slow down and pay attention.

Behavior control and leash pulling

In practice, I noticed the collar helps prevent sudden surges forward—especially on my more excitable walkers. The tightening is moderate and focused around the neck; it doesn’t apply a wide-compression like some thicker collars. This made corrections feel more precise and less abrasive. Over multiple walks, I saw measurable reductions in pulling because the dogs associated their movement with a clear, consistent cue.

Safety concerns and precautions

I take safety seriously, and I’ll be candid about what I watched for and what I recommend for use.

Preventing choking and injury

A slip collar can cause harm if used incorrectly—left tight, used for prolonged periods, or adjusted too short. I always used the collar only while on leash and training, and I never left it constantly on my dog. I recommend keeping the collar loose enough at rest so it doesn’t constrict when the dog breathes or moves their head. Quick-release or a separate flat collar is a better option for non-training periods.

When not to use this collar

I avoid using slip collars with dogs that have respiratory or tracheal issues, very young puppies without developed neck muscles, or dogs with neck injuries. I also do not use it for tethering or as a regular everyday collar. If your dog is highly reactive to neck pressure or panics with tightening devices, I prefer harnesses or consult a trainer for alternatives.

Real-world testing: My experience

I used the Slip Dog Training Choke Collar on three dogs across different sessions to get a range of feedback: a 5 kg terrier mix, a 12 kg small shepherd type, and an energetic 18 kg spaniel-ish dog (using an M for the latter when possible).

First impressions

Right out of the package the collar looked neat and well-made. Putting it on was straightforward: slide it over the head and adjust the loop. The leather-tailored piece held the ends securely, which gave me confidence in the collar’s integrity. The first walk with my terrier showed immediate attention changes—some head-turning and less lunging—which encouraged me to continue.

Training sessions over weeks

Over four to six weeks of regular use, I used the collar primarily for heel practice, controlled release commands, and stopping sudden dashes. My small terrier improved on leash manners and pulled less frequently. The 12 kg dog responded well to consistent cue timing, and the 18 kg dog required a larger collar but also showed fewer strong pulls with repeated, short training sessions. I paired corrections with positive reinforcement (treats and praise), which sped up the learning.

Pros and cons

I like to balance pros and cons so you can decide if this collar fits your needs.

Pros:

• Lightweight and comfortable for short-term training use.
• Smooth round nylon rope that slides easily and dries quickly.
• Leather-tailored connection seems durable and well-stitched.
• Washable and low-maintenance.
• Straightforward P-collar design provides clear, immediate cues for training.

Cons:

• Not suitable for continuous wear; should be used only during training or walks.
• Can cause irritation or red marks if overused or fitted too tightly.
• Minimal included instructions; beginners might need guidance on correct use.
• For larger, very strong pullers, heavier-duty options may be more appropriate.

Maintenance and cleaning

I prefer simple cleaning routines, and this collar fits that preference. Keeping it clean prolongs life and keeps it comfortable for the dog.

Washing instructions

I hand-washed the collar with mild soap and lukewarm water, paying attention to the leather connection. After rinsing thoroughly, I air-dried it flat away from direct heat. I avoided machine washing or tumbling because that could stress the leather and stitching. Light dirt and saliva wipe away easily between washes.

Storage and long-term care

I store the collar in a dry place away from sunlight to preserve the leather. If the leather looks dry over time, a small amount of leather conditioner can be applied carefully—avoiding excess that could transfer to the nylon. Regularly check the stitching and rope for fraying to catch wear before it becomes a safety issue.

Comparison with other collars

I often compare tools to know when each is appropriate. Here’s how this slip collar stacks up against common alternatives in my experience.

Versus flat collars

A flat collar is for everyday ID and gentle control. The slip collar is a training tool for specific behavior correction. I don’t replace a flat collar with the P-collar for daily wear because flat collars are safer for continuous use. For addressing leash-pulling, the slip collar offers faster, clearer feedback than a flat collar.

Versus martingale and harnesses

A martingale offers limited tightening and is a gentler alternative for dogs who slip out of collars. Harnesses distribute force over the body and are excellent for dogs with respiratory issues or small breeds. Compared to a martingale, this slip collar can offer stronger quick cues, but martingales are safer for dogs prone to slipping out. Compared to harnesses, the P-collar provides a neck-focused cue that many trainers prefer for certain behaviors like immediate stopping and attention.

Tips for safe, effective use

I want you to be successful and keep your dog safe. These are the practical steps I follow and recommend.

Fitting and setup steps

1. Measure your dog’s neck and choose the correct size based on the table earlier.
2. Put the collar over the dog’s head and position it high on the neck, just behind the ears—this gives better control and clearer cues.
3. Check that you can slip two fingers between the collar and the dog in the resting state to avoid tightness.
4. Use a short leash when practicing to keep corrections controlled and immediate.

Training tips and positive reinforcement

• Use short sessions (5–10 minutes) to teach the dog what the correction means, and reward compliance quickly with a treat or praise.
• Pair the collar cue with a verbal command like “easy” or “wait” so your dog learns the desired behavior.
• Avoid repetitive or constant pressure. The cue should be immediate and released as soon as your dog responds.
• If your dog becomes anxious, stop and use positive reinforcement instead—escalating pressure is not productive.

Troubleshooting common issues

I had a few small issues while using the collar and I’ll share how I fixed them so you can avoid the same mistakes.

Collar slipping or twisting

If the collar twists, reposition it higher on the neck and check that the leather connection is centered. A misalignment often comes from how the leash attaches; make sure the leash clips to the correct spot and that the collar sits flat against the neck. If it still twists, try a different leash clip angle or a short training lead that keeps tension straight.

Dog reacts badly or resists

If a dog panics or resists the collar, stop and switch to gentler methods. Gradual desensitization helps: introduce the collar calmly, pair it with treats while it’s loose, and only apply mild pressure once the dog is comfortable. For severe resistance, consult a professional trainer to ensure the approach is appropriate.

Frequently asked questions

I kept notes of common questions I had and questions I’ve been asked when recommending this collar.

Q: Is this collar painful? A: When used correctly, the collar provides a quick, moderate cue rather than prolonged pain. Proper fit and timing are essential to keep it humane.

Q: Can my dog wear this all the time? A: No. I don’t recommend leaving a slip collar on continuously. Use it during training or supervised walks only.

Q: Will it break if my dog pulls hard? A: The nylon and leather are reasonably durable, but extreme force over time may stress the connection. Inspect regularly and replace if any wear appears. For very strong pullers, consider a heavy-duty alternative.

Q: Is it safe for puppies? A: Young puppies have delicate necks. I avoid using slip collars on very young puppies; instead I use harnesses and gentle training methods until their necks mature.

Q: How do I prevent hair tangling? A: Position the collar high and avoid leaving it on while the dog plays unsupervised. For long-haired dogs, combing regularly and checking under the collar helps.

Final verdict and recommendation

After weeks of hands-on use, I feel the Slip Dog Training Choke Collar – Round Nylon Rope No Pull P-Collar for Small Medium Large Dogs (Black S) is a practical, well-made tool for owners who want a lightweight, effective collar for short-term training. I appreciate the straightforward design, washable nylon rope, and leather-tailored connection. For small to medium dogs who need clear cues to reduce pulling, this collar is a useful option when used responsibly.

I recommend it for owners who: want a simple training tool, are willing to learn correct fit and timing, will use it only during supervised sessions, and pair corrections with positive reinforcement. I do not recommend it for continuous use, for dogs with neck or respiratory problems, or for owners unfamiliar with safe slip-collar techniques without professional guidance. If you keep those points in mind, this collar can be a reliable part of your training toolkit.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.